I’ve been quiet lately, but not by choice. A month ago my grandfather fell and broke his hip. Two weeks ago, on his sixty-fourth wedding anniversary, he died. Our family is small; the loss is large. For the next little while I might prefer silence to writing on topics that seem – temporarily – so inconsequential.

He was born in 1922, a baby in the glittering summer of Gatsby. Sibelius was working on his sixth symphony; Ravel, his Pictures orchestration. His young mother had only recently earned the right to vote. These happenings feel dusty and old, events from another epoch. The fact that my grandfather’s timeline intersected theirs leaves me astonished. I’m not sure if that astonishment means I’ve mis-judged the distance of time, or if he out-lived his own age. Probably both.


As a young man – younger than me – he risked his life in the battlefields of Europe in the greatest war the world has ever known. Earlier this year he was awarded the French Legion of Honor for his service. He received the medal with characteristic modesty and an intensely quiet pleasure. As the nearest grandchild, I was asked to type the application letter. Our respective accomplishments as twentysomethings were jarring: one freed Europe from Hitler, the other…typed quickly. As I was preparing the application I copied a yellowed military paper. In unemotional typewritten font I caught a glimpse of what he had been compelled to do. I pretended I hadn’t and saved my crying for later. Because of what was on that paper, the barefaced horror of works by men like Messiaen and Shostakovich will always echo loudly in my heart.

And yet – he hated music by men like Messiaen and Shostakovich. He considered Brahms avant-garde. It is mainly because of him that I’ve questioned the idea that orchestral music belongs most naturally to members of his generation. In my family, the older you are, the less likely it is that symphonic music speaks to you.

Which isn’t to say my grandfather didn’t love music. He did. His radio was always on, usually playing something from the early classical era – or a polka. He supported my mother’s musical studies and she in turn supported mine. He spoke admiringly of the work of composers like Bach and Beethoven, who composed their millions of notes by hand and by candlelight. But his affection for music was restricted to pieces that were pleasant and beautiful: pieces that made him happy. Composers who sought to come to terms with the horror of his war, he had no interest in knowing. Upon reflection, this is understandable.

Among other things, my grandfather was a teacher and a counselor. In more ways than one, he had a teacher’s voice. Between the two of them, my grandfather and his teacher wife earned a fistful of college degrees. They encouraged the values most beloved by teachers: curiosity, discipline, hard work. When I was in school, every conversation began with: “What are you learning?” After I graduated, every conversation began with: “What are you reading?” More often than not he could discourse easily on whatever arcane subject I would answer with. On the rare occasion he was unfamiliar with the topic at hand, he would begin a round of incessant questioning, even when his doing so irritated or embarrassed those around him. Until the day he fell, he surfed the Internet, reading, researching, scribbling down URLs in unreadable longhand cursive. He made it very clear to me that I was never to take this miracle technology for granted. I’ve tried not to. I’ve often hoped I will always approach the Internet with the same sense of childlike wonder that he did. “If we had had this during the war…” he said, many times.

And yet I think he fully appreciated the irony that he was using such magical technology to forward Ole and Lena jokes to his friends. His greatest legacy was his delight in absurdity, his love of laughter.

One of his favorite activities was looking up names online. Occasionally he’d look up mine, and visit the blog. He was always impressed by the quality of the men and women I met in music, and doubly so during the Minnesota Orchestra lockout. Over the last two years, the question “What are you reading?” was gradually supplanted by “What’s happening with The Orchestra?” He never heard The Orchestra, but The Orchestra was important to him because it was important to me. He was actually one of the handful of people who knew my vaguely forming plans for the future of the blog; in fact, that was the subject of one of the last conversations he ever had. We never discussed it explicitly, but I think he could see that over the past two years I’ve found a voice, and that I’ve found something I love to do, and that I’m good at doing: that, one way or another, I will be taken care of. It’s a great gift to be able to share that knowledge with someone who has supported you, who has instilled the values that will serve you well on your own journey.

My violin turns ten years old this week. My grandparents bought it at considerable personal sacrifice to them. It is a tangible symbol of the values they’ve encouraged: curiosity, discipline, hard work – both in the artistry it took for its maker to construct it, and in the small ability I’ve nurtured to be able to play it. Every evening as I practice I meditate, consciously or unconsciously, on my rich inheritance. Perhaps now the ease with which the violin speaks will remind me of the ease of his laughter; the dark lower strings, the tragedies that came so close to breaking him; and the silvery E-string, the faith he had in me until the day he died.

Some words from Cymbeline:

Fear no more the heat o’ th’ sun
    Nor the furious winter’s rages;
Thou thy worldly task hast done,
    Home art gone and ta’en thy wages…

Fear no more the frown o’ th’ great;
    Thou art past the tyrant’s stroke.
Care no more to clothe and eat;
    To thee the reed is as the oak.
The sceptre, learning, physic, must
All follow this and come to dust…

Nothing ill come near thee.
Quiet consummation have,
And renowned be thy grave.



Filed under Personal stuff

17 responses to “Eulogy

  1. Emily–I’m just a casual reader, but I’m glad you wrote about your grandfather. What an encourager!

  2. Michael B.

    Emily: I’ve never met your grandfather; I’ve never met you (except for on these pages). But I feel like I know him a little bit now. Thank you. Sympathy to you and your family.

  3. hyperchord

    Thank you for sharing this.

  4. jrettger

    Emily, if you ever meet an old man who bursts into tears as he shakes your hand, that person would be me. Your wonderful and truthful and thoughtful essay on your grandfather, coupled with the beautiful music, was very moving.

  5. I started following you during the Minnesota lock out and I have only been impressed by the things I have read and learned from you. Now I see that you ability to inspire and inform others had come from an excellent source.

    I was never close to any of my grandparents – they all live in Brazil – and sometimes wish that I had a connection with them the way you did with your grandfather. Hold onto your memories and your blessings.

    Thank you for sharing a piece of your heart with us. My condolences to you and your family. Please know you will be in my prayers tonight.

  6. Karin

    Emily, You made me cry….good tears. Thank you for this.

  7. Bob

    Emily, your grandfather was blessed to have such a loving and talented granddaughter to remember him so well. May his memory be a blessing to you and may he rest in peace.

  8. What a lovely, and moving tribute to your grandfather. Treasure the memories of good times spent with him. Play beautiful music in his honor. I thank you for sharing your grief so publicly. My sincere thoughts of sympathy go out to you and your family. Know that in your heart, you made your grandfather proud for being who you are.

  9. Dave Assemany

    I love you Emily. <3.

  10. Thank you for writing about your grandfather, Emily. I’m sorry for your loss, and happy for your memories.

  11. Pingback: Eulogy | World of Violins

  12. Stuard Young

    Dear Emily, You have written a beautiful and especially moving piece about your grandfather. My mother was also born in 1922, and I lost her just three months ago. Your Eulogy brought many memories to the fore. She was the one who set me on my musical path. Like your grandfather, my mother’s musical taste did not go much farther into the 20th century than Puccini, Mahler and Richard Strauss, but she encouraged me to explore for myself. Her avid reading of books on almost any subject instilled a passion for learning. Becoming a music educator was a very natural life path for me as a result of these influences. I am sure that you will never forget the many contributions your grandfather made to your life. I discovered this piece for orchestra just before my father passed away suddenly more than 25 years ago, and it has given me solace whenever I am missing loved ones: Chant Funebre, Op. 9, by the underrated composer, Alberich Magnard. The nobility of its subtle, nuanced emotional expression is like no other music I know. Peace to you and your family.

  13. Thanks for the inspiration and the importance of family. Readers must appreciate the insight into your life. You and the other bloggers have been a very positive force for change. Do return to us as you are ready to take up the task of the advocate for the arts.

  14. You are such a lovely writer. I’m sure he would be proud to have a little of the love you shared memorialized here.

  15. Kevin Kooiker

    A very nice tribute to your grandfather. He must have been proud of your writing!

Leave a Reply to kirkistan Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s